ST. MARY'S DIAMOND JUBILEE PROGRAM AND MENU

MENU
__




Grapefruit Rubyette


Cream of Tomato Soup


Crouton Souffle


Golden Celery Hearts Chilled Olives Rose Radishes


Roast Chemung County Broad Breast Trukey


Mark Twain Dressing


Orange and Cranberry Sauce


Candied Southern Yam Fresh Garden Beans en Beurre

Salade Bon Ton


Lorenzo Dressing


Fancy Flormed Ice Cream


Peits Fours Coffee
PROGRAM
__


INVOCATION…………..………..….Most Rev. James E. Kearney, Bishop of Rochester

TOASTMASTER……………….……………..…….……………..…Mr. James L. Burke

GREETINGS FROM THE CITY….…………..….……..The Honorable Emory Strachen

FOR THE FORMER ASSISTANT PASTORS
OF ST. MARY’S……………………………………..…..…Rev. George V. Predmore

FOR THE TRUSTEES OF ST. MARY’S……………...…….………….Mr. W.H. O’Neil

FOR THE PEOPLE OF ST. MARY’S………….………..….Mr. David Vincent Sheehan

REMARKS……………..…………..……..….Rev. Thomas J. Toole, Pastor of St. Mary’s

ADDRESS………………………....….Most Rev. James E. Kearney, Bishop of Rochester



_______________



MUSIC………………………………………………..………………..Miss Loretta Ryan


Hostesses – Mrs. Fred B. Yeisley, Chairman. The Misses Jean Titus, Rose Alice Frawley, Mary Claire Hayes, Rita Mailey, Jeanne McCarthy, Margaret O’Beirne, Theresa Hogan, Mary Catherine Reagan, Elizabeth Turner, Carol Baker

St. Mary's Diamond Jubilee Decication and cover

DIAMOND JUBILEE



A History of the
Parish and Its School
An Account of the Activities
That Have Transpired in
St. Mary’s Parish from Its
Foundation through the
DIAMOND JUBILEE
Held in May, Nineteen Forty-eight


ST. MARY’S CHURCH
ELMIRA, NEW YORK



Dedication

This booklet is dedicated to the priests, sisters and people who have made St. Mary’s Parish what it is, under the patronage of Our Lady of the Assumption. May She continue to bless these good people in their efforts forever. For “Never was it known that anyone who had recourse to Her Protection, implored Her Assistance, or sought Her Intercession was left unaided”.

Most Rev. James E. Kearney, D.D. Bishop of Rochester

Sincere congratulations to the Parish of Saint Mary on the completion of seventy-five years. Only the Angels of God can record properly the magnificent story. In our humble way we can pay tribute to the great figures of the past, within the Sanctuary and in the pews, whose work made that history. In thanking God for the blessings of the past, we beg His blessing upon the work which lies ahead. (signed James E. Kearney)

Rt. Rev. Msgr. William J. Brien V.F., Dean of the Elmira Deanery

Dear Father Toole:

We are very happy to extend our sincere congratulations on the occasion of the diamond jubilee of St. Mary’s Parish.
St. Mary’s has played an important part in preserving and spreading the Faith in this Community for the past seventy-five years. This was made possible by the zeal of the priests and nuns who served over this long period, and the parishioners who cooperated so willingly in everything that pertained to the welfare of the Church and their parish.
St. Mary’s can well be proud of its accomplishments during these years, and it is our sincere prayer that God will continue to shower His blessings upon you and your people.
This festive occasion is enhanced by the celebration of the silver jubilee of your ordination to the priesthood. It is only fitting that you should celebrate with the parish for which you have done so much. May God reward you for your priestly zeal over this period of years, and my He strengthen you for many more years in His service.
Sincerely yours in Christ,
(signed William J. Brien)

Father Toole

Father Toole was born in Geneva, N.Y., October 14, 1896. He attended St. Francis De Sales Grammar School and Geneva High School from which he was graduated in 1915. He took his college course at Holy Cross College at Worcester, Mass. Father Toole studied for the priesthood at St. Bernard’s Seminary, Rochester, N.Y., and was ordained June 9th, 1923. His first assignment was as assistant pastor at the Church of the Immaculate Conception at Ithaca, N.Y. He left in September, 1924 for study at Cambridge University, Cambridge, England where he pursued a course in English, and Public Speaking. After his return in 1927, he taught English at Aquinas Institute, Rochester, N.Y., in 1928 and 1929. He was appointed assistant pastor to Holy Family Parish, Auburn, N.Y. in July 1929. In September of the same year, Father Toole was appointed to the faculty of Elmira College in the Dept. of Bible and Religion and remained on the staff until July, 1944. In January, 1935, he was appointed first resident pastor of St. Chas. of Borromeo in Elmira Heights. On January 11, 1944, Father Toole was appointed pastor of St. Mary’s, Elmira, N.Y.

Father Lane

Father Lane was born in Auburn, N.Y., June 8, 1908, where he attended St. Mary’s Parochial School and Auburn High School. He studied for the priesthood at St. Andrew’s and St. Bernard’s Seminaries and was ordained at St. Patrick’s in Rochester, N.Y., June 15, 1935. In July of the same year, he was appointed assistant pastor of St. Michael’s Church, Newark, N.Y. In January, 1941, Father Lane was commissioned First Lt. In the Chaplain’s Corps of the U.S. Army. He was called to active duty in March, 1941 when he was assigned to the First Armored Division at Fr. Knox, Ky. Father Lane served overseas in the African and Italian Theaters for 28 months. Upon his return to the United States, he served 18 months as Assistant Service Command Chaplain at Dallas, Tex. and for one year as Assistant Fifth Army Chaplain at Chicago, Ill. He was placed on the inactive status in the officer’s reserve corps with the rank of Lt. Col. in June, 1947. Father Lane was assigned as an assistant pastor to St. Mary’s, Elmira in July, 1947.

Father Lynch

Father Lynch was born in Rochester, N.Y., May 23, 1918. He started grammar school in the School of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary at Brockport, N.Y. and completed his primary education at St. Theodore School, Gates, N.Y. Father Lynch studied for the priesthood at St. Andrew’s and St. Bernard’s Seminaries in Rochester, N.Y. He was ordained to the Holy Priesthood by the Most Rev. Jas, E. Kearney on December 18, 1943. He was appointed assistant pastor at St. Mary’s Church, Elmira, N.Y., on January 11, 1944.

History of St. Mary's Church Elmira, NY

According to the “History of the Catholic Church of Western New York” St. Mary’s was the fourth parish to be established in Elmira. The Rev. Sheridan was pastor in Binghamton in 1845. He occasionally visited in Elmira and all the other little towns through several counties in this portion of the state. Elmira grew more rapidly than the other towns in the vicinity and Father Sheridan took up residence in Elmira in 1849 and bought a house for a parochial residence and built a brick church for the little congregation which he had organized as the first parish in Elmira. This first church was dedicated to St. Peter and St. Paul.

The German Catholics of Elmira attended the church of St. Peter’s and St. Paul’s until they were formed into a congregation of their own in 1866. As early as 1857 a German priest occasionally visited and encouraged them to organize into a congregation. They bought property on Dickinson St. and started a little church building, the cornerstone of which was laid in 1866 and was consecrated in the fall of 1868. New property was bought and a cornerstone of the new church was laid in 1891 at the corner of Lake and Second Sts. This church was consecrated in 1892 by Bishop Ryan. This second parish was dedicated to St. John the Baptist.

The northern part of the town had a boom in 1868 from a large iron works, and from the railroad life and works in that section of the city. Bishop Ryan of Buffalo sent the Rev. T.R. Hopkins in 1868 to organize a new parish in that part of town. He purchased a beautiful site in a favorable locality, but his health failed and he died in July of the following year. Bishop Ryan was absent in Rome at the time of Father Hopkins death and the Very Rev. Gleason who directed the affairs of the diocese in the absence of the Bishop appointed the Rev. J.J. Bloomer to the new parish of St. Patrick’s in Elmira. Father Bloomer erected a temporary church the following year which served the congregation until the handsome brick structure was ready for the use of the people. Father Bloomer began work on the permanent church shortly after his advent to Elmira and it was dedicated on the 13th of September, 1874. This third parish was dedicated to St. Patrick. In the same history we read “The southern portion of Elmira across the Chemung River known as Southport grew rapidly about the year 1870 and it soon became necessary to organize another parish for this part of the town. The large shops drew many working men to this portion of the city and the houses sprang up here rapidly and were occupied by men employed by the works in this vicinity. The Rev. Jas. McManus was sent here in 1872 to organize the new parish of St. Mary’s.” This was the fourth parish established in Elmira.

New Main Altar and Baldachino

________________________
From the earliest records of St. Mary’s Parish, there is a notation in Father McManus’ own handwriting that he was appointed as pastor to St. Mary’s in Elmira on Feb. 19, 1872 where he served as pastor until April 1880, when he was transferred to St. Joseph Church, Batavia, N.Y., where he died in 1882.

The original property of St. Mary’s Parish was purchased August 21, 1871, when Jas. And Mary McCrudden transferred to Jas. C. McManus for $1,600.00 one acre of land at Franklin and Fulton Sts. Extending 290 feet along Fulton St. by 148.2 feet on Franklin St. On August 21, 1875, this same property was transferred to the Rt. Rev. Stephen Vincent Ryan, Bishop of Buffalo in consideration for a mortgage of $6,000.00 made to John Arnot Jr. The first transaction was recorded with the County Clerk of Chemung Co. on January 19, 1874, and the second with the same on August 27, 1875.

Construction was begun on this property almost immediately following the advent of the new pastor as evidenced from an article from the Daily Advertiser under the date of Feb. 22, 1872.

“NEW CATHOLIC CHURCH”

“Yesterday ground was broken by the Catholics for the erection of a new church edifice at their lot, corner of Franklin and Fulton Streets in the fifth ward. They have undertaken the erection of a wooden building for the present church uses until the completion of the brick edifice originally contemplated. The present temporary structure will then be used as a schoolhouse. Father Ryan, the new pastor, is pushing the work with vigor.”

New Church

After a diligent search through many records, we have found it impossible to find anything on the Father Ryan mentioned in the above story carried in the Daily Advertiser under the above date, but some light will be shed on this position in the article from the Daily Advertiser on Monday, February 26, 1872.

“CATHOLIC INTELLIGENCE”

“The ardor with which the Catholics of the fifth ward entered upon their new church enterprise a day or two ago has just received a somewhat sudden though perhaps not serious check. Their earnest desire for a suitable house of worship has developed into vigorous efforts to build one with the active cooperation of their young pastor, Rev. Father Ryan recently appointed to that church. Having some reason later to anticipate his removal in the midst of their good work, a resourceful and numerously signed petition was forwarded to the Bishop of the diocese asking him to continue their beloved young pastor with them at least for the present. Other counsels, however, seem to have prevailed. Two days ago he received a summons from his Bishop to report to Buffalo. His late flock are very much disappointed at this turn of events. Rev. Father McManus, late of Watkins, has been transferred to this parish and assigned today as the successor of Father Ryan. Mr. McManus is an energetic and talented gentleman and sometimes high in the estimation of hi ecclesiastical superiors.

“Yesterday Rev. Father Ryan preached at St. Peter & Paul’s church. He announced that his sermon was to be his last one to that congregation as he was about to leave this parish. His first experience in the ministry took place among his hearers in this city. Here he said his first Mass and preached his first sermon about six months ago. It was but natural that his experiences in Elmira and the circumstances should make strong impressions on his mind. Assigned to the work of building the new church in the fifth ward, he had been brought into intimate contact with the Catholics of that locality. Their religious zeal and their liberality was an honor to their faith and made them worthy desciples [sic] of Ireland’s great apostle, St. Patrick. Toward him they had always exhibited uniform kindness and sincere courtesies and wherever he should be hereafter, he would alway [sic] cherish with the deepest gratitude the remembrance of their sympathy and good feeling for him. He concluded by asking their prayers for his future success. During his sermon, many of his hearers were affected to tears. During his brief sojourn here, the Reverend gentleman had endeared himself by his many excellent personal qualities to his people.”

Rev. James McManus

First Pastor of St. Mary's

___________________

The taking over of St. Mary’s by Father McManus is announced in an article in the Daily Advertiser, dated Monday, March 4, 1872 under the heading “New Catholic Clergyman.”

Yesterday at the church of St. Peter & Paul’s, Rev. Father McManus formally announced his new relationship to the recently organized Catholic congregation in the fifth ward. He read a letter from the Bishop of Buffalo investing him with the requisite authority and instructing him in the duties of his position. Were he guided by other than supernatural motives, he said he would not now be in this place. Had he consulted his own comforts and preferences, he should have remained in his more pleasant position at Watkins. His faith, however, enjoined upon him the duty of implicit obedience. In compliance, therefore, with the obligations of his sacred calling, he came among them in obedience to the instructions of his Bishop. He would discharge the duties of his new position to the best of his ability.

The Reverend gentleman is a graceful and pleasing speaker and made a very favorable impression upon his hearers. His late flock at Watkins is parting with him with much regret. They sought to retain his services by a numerously signed petition to their Bishop to permit him to remain there a little while longer, but it is not the usage of Catholic prelates to recognize such appeals in their administration of their church affairs. Under his energetic auspices, Catholic interests flourished remarkably in Watkins. From the impression this gentleman has made among the people of his new charge, it is reasonable to expect that like success will crown his administration in Elmira.

Rev. Father Ryan, late of this place, has been appointed as Assistant Clergyman at St. Bridget’s church in Buffalo, which is under the charge of Rev. Father Gleason, the Vicar General of the diocese. This is one of the wealthiest Catholic parishes in Buffalo.

That Father McManus began construction on the temporary Church at once is evidenced from his journal where there are notations beginning March 29, 1872 for the purchase of stone, lumber and carpenter work. It may be of interest in passing to note that the receipts for this first year totaled $7,050.00. At the dedication of the church on May 12, the collection amounted to $337.00 a subscription on June 30th brought him $523.00 and a picnic and festival on August 15th netted $1,300.00. It is also interesting to note that the rectory must have been started this year. Under the date of October 31, there was a subscription for the presbytery which totaled $1,890.000 [sic]. In December, of the same year a Fair and Festival, the Christmas Collection, Pew Rents and other collections netted a total of $3,000.00.

St. Mary's Rectory
______________

The next article is from the Daily Advertiser under the date of May 13, 1872. This was the dedication of the temporary church.

If one would know with what rapidity this city of ours is growing, he has but to spend a few hours in and about the suburbs over in the fifth ward where the heretofore vacant space between the river and the Northern Central shops has thickened up with houses and much population. Meeting the wants of the people of that new neighborhood who have been obliged to come a long distance to the church on High Street, the Catholics at the corner of Franklin and Fulton Streets have put up a new church. It is as it stands now but a temporary structure, but it is a nucleus around which will hereafter grown an edifice that will be a pride to the people and a source of pleasure and satisfaction to the residents of that part of the city. To Father McManus, a newcomer in this locality – a thriving busy driving man – is due this new enterprise, and under his guidance without the shadow of a doubt, his church will increase and multiply and grow strong.

Yesterday morning a new church under the name of St. Mary’s was dedicated. It was not entirely finished, but enough of it is to accommodate with comfort the large crowd that jammed its way through the portals to witness the solemn ceremony. The Bishop of this diocese (Buffalo) was expected to be present and deliver the address, but he could not come an in his stead sent the Very Reverend Dr. Quigley, his Vicar General. To assist him in the ceremonies besides Father McManus, the clergyman of the parish, there were Father Clark of Sts. Peter and Paul’s and Father Bloomer of St. Patrick’s. The address was delivered by Vicar General Quigley. It was pointed and apt for the occasion, the main idea running throughout the discourse being the holy character of the building dedicated to the service of the Lord. Mass was celebrated by Father McManus. The services were all of that impressive character that marks the ritual of the Romish Church whether observed in the humblest of buildings or the grandest cathedrals.

They were rendered if not the more striking – at least more inspiring and satisfactory to one not of the congregation – by the exquisite singing of Miss Butler, the soprano connected with the “Mirror of Ireland” lately exhibiting at the Opera House in the city. She sang the “Ave Maria” with expression and feeling that touched one’s sensibilities very strongly, and her rich full voice in the choruses made the hearers involuntarily remember all of those beautiful things that have been heard of the music of the Catholic Church. Mr. O’Connell, the pianist of the troupe, presided at the organ and did it in a masterly manner. The whole ceremony connected with the dedication, the bright beautiful day, the devout manner of the attendants and the great crowd struck this observer as an auspicious beginning of the new church, and that the need in this quarter of the city had been fully met.

The first baptism in St. Mary’s Parish took place May 19th, 1872. Mary Liddy, born May 15, 1872, the daughter of Michael Liddy and Catherine McCormack, his wife. The sponsors were Francis Riley and Many Monaghan. She was baptized by Father McManus.

The first marriage in St. Mary’s Parish was solemnized August 11, 1872, between Peter French and Emma Smith. The witnesses being Patrick Daly, and Anna Daly. This marriage was performed by Father McManus.

BUILDING ST. MARY'S CHURCH

The next great event to take place in the history of St. Mary’s was the laying of the corner stone of the new church and we follow with articles from the Daily Advertiser:

LAYING OF A CORNER STONE

The corner stone of the new St. Mary’s Catholic Church in the fifth ward, Rev. J. McManus, pastor, will be laid tomorrow morning at ten o’clock with appropriate ceremonies. Rt. Rev. Steven Vincent Ryan, Bishop of Buffalo, will be present and officiate. The Bishop of Rochester has also been notified to be present. St. Mary’s is situated on the corner of Fulton and Franklin Streets and is to be a structure that will be of considerable credit to that part of the city. When finished, it will cost in the neighborhood of $25,000. The event of the laying of the corner stone should call out to attend upon the ceremonies a large number of people. That portion of the city of Elmira has claims on the whole city which in such matters should not be ignored.

The different Catholic societies of the city are to meet at the corner of Main and Water Streets tomorrow morning at nine o’clock to attend upon the ceremonies.

Bishop Ryan will administer the rite of confirmation at the church at three o’clock in the afternoon tomorrow. (Daily Advertiser – Oct. 4, 1873).

CORNER STONE LAYING

Yesterday morning the corner stone of the new Catholic church in the fifth ward, Rev. J. McManus, pastor, was laid with appropriate ceremonies. There was a large number of people present. The Emmett Band playing some very fine music led the two Catholic societies, St. Peter & Paul’s Benevolent and the Father Matthew Temperance, to the church. Rt. Rev. S.V. Ryan, Bishop of Buffalo, performed the ceremonies, assisted by Rev. Father Cunningham of St. Peter & Paul’s. Rev. Father Bloomer of St. Patrick’s of this city, Rev. P. Kinsella of Wellsville and Rev. J. McManus, pastor of St., Mary’s. The usual papers, coins, and momentoes [sic] were place din the box and the ceremonies were of an impressive character. The pastor of the church has reason to be congratulated for the advance made thus far and to work hopefully in the future for the welfare of his church and his people. (Daily Advertiser, Oct. 6, 1873.)

Shortly after the cornerstone laying, there was a Fair at the old Military Hall, and we quote form the Elmira Daily Advertiser under the date of October 16th, 1873.

ST. MARY’S CHURCH FAIR

The fair of St. Mary’s Church at Military Hall is progressing with spirit and profit. There was a very large attendance there last evening and the receipts were such as must have been pleasing to the people of the church and their energetic and highly esteemed pastor, Rev. J. McManus. The fair is to last through the week and as the days advance there will be attractions added that cannot fail to increase the attendance until it becomes a throng and as well the amounts to be put into the church treasury. There are many articles of value in usefulness on sale and the usual amount of pretty women going about with small books desiring that you try your fortune for this, that or the other articles displayed on the tables. Every one seems to be enjoying himself and when that is the case, it must certainly be followed by an increase to the income to the fair. Father McManus and those with him interest him in the undertaking, for no fears of the ultimate result that will attend upon their well directed efforts.

ST. MARY’S CHURCH FAIR

The success of the fair of St. Mary’s Church at Military Hall is as pronounced as ever. Notwithstanding the threatening storm that came up about the usual hour that people start out for the evening, the attendance at the hall last night was as flattering as ever. Two more days and evenings remain and the friends of the church and the people still have an opportunity of doing much for the cause that recommends itself to their favorable consideration. (Daily Advertiser, Oct. 17, 1873).

In October or November of 1873, the partly completed walls of the church fell in, but we have been unable to find any article describing this calamity. It is referred to in a similar disaster which happened on Thursday, December 4, 1873. We again quote from the Elmira Daily Advertiser. Friday, December 5, 1873.

ST. MARY’S CHURCH

THE NEW BUILDING FLUNG DOWN BY A GALE OF WIND, THREE WORKMEN INJURED; ON PROBABLY FATALLY, LOSS $8,000.

A second ad similar calamity as the one four weeks ago overtook the new building of St. Mary’s Church in the fifth ward yesterday. Between one and two o’clock, a steady gale of wind, which had been blowing during the morning, increased to such intensity that it suddenly demolished the walls of the building flinging them over in an eastward direction. About the premises were twelve or fifteen men employed, three carpenters, four masons and the rest of them laborers or tenders. The side walls were up. The masons were at work about the tower and Arthur Birchell and William Tushingham putting on the end wall bricking up toward the roof. The carpenters were engaged in staying the roof timbers, which were already in place and better boarded over to receive the slate by fastening ropes to the rafters and beams and staying them among the floor timbers below.
One carpenter, Martin Flanigan, was among the roof timbers and the other two below. He and the masons described that for a moment the walls of the building seemed to sway forward and then the wall fell with a tremendous crash, the roof timbers laying on top of the ruins. The two carpenters inside got warning and started out of the building just in time to save their lives while their companion aloft came down with a crash and through some strength of providence escaped instantaneous death by the timbers around him and received only internal injuries which were not serious. The masons, Birchell and Tushingham, were not so fortunate. Their descent was amid the tumbled brick work. The former had a leg broken and the latter has received such internal injuries including compression of the brain that it was greatly feared he would not survive the night. Flanigan and Tushingham were removed to the Surgical Institute where their injuries were skillfully treated, and Birchell was taken to his home in the Buttonwoods where his limb was adjusted and dressed by Dr. A.H. Flood. All the rest of the men about the building escaped, only slight scratches being received in one or two instances. The east wall in its descent was flung against the side of the parsonage bursting in and destroying the library and sliding the wall building about two feet from its foundation. The resident priest was away. Father McManus was absent from this city at Lockport attending the death of a fellow priest who was killed a few days ago, but a sister and servant in the house were prostrated with fright but suffered no injuries. The church edifice was 60 x 112 on the ground with additions besides. About four weeks ago a similar calamity happened too. Only the walls were not so far along and the roof timbers were in place but not covered. The mason contractor was Patrick Murray. The contractor for carpenters work was M. McGovern, old and experienced builders. The loss is estimated at $8,000.00. Rebuilding will probably be entered upon but whether now or in the spring is not known until Father McManus returns.

All in all its [sic] was wonderful that so few were injured. It was a fearful accident. The congregation at St. Mary’s will have general sympathy under the strokes of repeated calamity but their energies and faith will overcome misfortunes and they will yet see a church of their people at last rising permanently out of these prostrated calamities.

The generosity of the many friends of St. Mary’s was immediately expressed after these misfortunes, when Bishop Ryan and many of the neighboring parishes including Watkins, Hornellesville, Corning, Waverly and St. Peter and St. Paul’s in Elmira took up collections and presented the pastor of St. Mary’s with a total of $800.00 to help defray the expenses of the damage done. A very touching note is struck in the account in the Daily Advertiser under the date of December 27, 1873 where it is noted.

“In spite of the events which cast a gloom over this church by the disasters which have overtaken their attempts to erect a new church, the congregation is firmly united and hopeful for the future. Father McManus therefore directed the Christmas Services in a very touching and impressive way.”

A still further misfortune dogged the construction of the church, and we quote from an article in the Elmira Daily Gazette dated January 12, 1875.

“Mr. J.K. Gillespie, a slater employed by the Elmira Slate Co., while at work on the new Catholic Church in Southport made a misstep and fell from the ridge to the ground, striking on a picket fence and a pile of lumber. His right arm was broken and a little finger of his left hand dislocated – besides this he received an ugly gash on his head and chin and several bruises about his body. He is however more comfortable than could be expected and it is hoped he has received no internal injuries. His escape from instant death is truly wonderful. The distance he slid along the room being about 30 feet and from there a direct fall to the ground of about 30 more.”

The next article of interest was a picnic that was held the following summer.


ST. MARY’S CHURCH PICNIC


Father McManus, assisted by the members of St. Mary’s Catholic Church, is arranging for a grand picnic to take place the third and fifth of July. Preparations are being made on a large scale and a happy time is anticipated. A parade of the church and school, with the line probably augmented by the various benevolent societies of that church, will occur on the fifth. The picnic is to be held at Hoffman’s Grove, where an interesting programme will be carried out. The proceeds of the enterprise which may be realized at the grove or elsewhere are to be applied toward the finishing of St. Mary’s Church.

The church is so well advanced toward completion that it is expected the work of frescoing it will be commenced by to-day. It is hoped that the receipts of the picnic will go far toward paying for the completion of the church.

This brings us up to what we can all imagine must have been a red letter day in the history of St. Mary’s Parish – its dedication – which took place on August 15, 1875 and we quote from the Elmira Daily Advertiser of August 13, 1875:

DEDICATION OF ST. MARY’S

On Sunday next the magnificent church structure in the 5th ward recently erected by Father McManus will be dedicated by the Right Reverend Bishop Ryan of Buffalo, assisted possibly by Bishop Lynch of Charleston, and a large number of clergymen from this and other dioceses.

The service will begin at 10:00 I the morning when Pontifical High Mass will be celebrated by Bishop Ryan and dedicatory ceremonies commenced. In the afternoon a large number of children whom Father McManus has had in careful training for weeks will receive the sacrament of Confirmation from the Bishop.

Extensive arrangements have been made to have the attendance at the ceremonies as large as possible. The Catholic Societies of Watkins, Waverly and Horseheads have been invited to attend and each have promised to be present in large numbers. Fortunately for the Watkins Societies, the Northern Central Railroad has an excursion train running that morning which leaves Watkins at 8:30 and arrives in Elmira at 9:15. This will afford a splendid opportunity to get to Elmira for attending the dedication for all who live between this city and Watkins as the train will stop at every station. The Horseheads Society of that place will take the cars. The Waverly Society will arrive on the Erie train which is due here at 9:15 a.m.

A delegation of presidents of the several Catholic organizations and the St. Mary’s (T.A.& B.) Society of this city escorted by the Emmett Band will go to the depot to meet the Societies from abroad on their arrival.

As is customary on occasions of this kind, the Catholic Societies of Elmira together with societies who come from other places, will attend the dedication in a body and be present at the ceremony. The Societies are asked to form on 3rd Street near the depot with the right resting on Main Street at 9:00 a.m. Please observe the following order of procession:

Grand Marshall Cook
St. Mary’s T.A.&B. – Watkins
Catholic Temperance Society – Waverly
St. Mary’s T.A.& B. – Horseheads
St. Peter & Paul’s Benevolent Society
Father Mathew Temperance Society, CYMB & TA
St. Patrick’s T.A. & B.
St. Mary’s T.A. & B.
Catholic Knights of Temperance.
Assistant Grand Marshalls. John Murphy
Michael Reidy
Edward Hennessey
Patrick Sullivan
Timothy O’Leary


Lines of march have been laid out as follows: Form on 3rd St. and at 9:30 move down Main and across Main St. Bridge to Franklin St. to St. Mary’s Church where they will remain during the ceremony. As soon as the services are over, the lines will reform on Fulton St. and move down Fulton St. to Hudson, down Hudson St. to Main, along Main and across the bridge to Water, thus down Water to the halls of the respective organizations. All of the societies are requested to be at their places of meeting as early as 8:15 a.m. in order to be on 3rd St. promptly at 9:00 a.m.

ST. MARY’S CHURCH ARRANGEMENTS FOR THE DEDICATION TOMORROW


As announced, St. Mary’s Church will be dedicated tomorrow by Bishop Ryan of Buffalo, assisted by many clergymen from this and other dioceses. The ceremony will be of the imposing character usual on such occasions and will commence at 10:00 in the forenoon. No admission will be charged at the door and all money to be taken up in the church will be given in the generosity and liberality of all who may attend. It is hoped that the people will appreciate, as they should, the noble work Father McManus has accomplished in the erection of the church and that they will show their appreciation by liberal contributions.

The sermon at the conclusion of the dedicatory ceremonies, it is expected, will be delivered by Bishop Ryan and a pleasant and forceful effort is assured.

No one need remain away in expecting not to be able to find seats as the church is exceedingly spacious and has a seating capacity of about one thousand. Besides this excellent accommodation, there are other temporary seats at each meeting which can readily be brought into requisition, (Daily Advertiser, Aug. 14, 1875).

DEDICATION OF ST. MARY'S CHURCH

Under the date of Aug. 16, the same paper described in great detail the ceremonies of the dedication.


“DEDICATION OF ST. MARY’S CHURCH”

Yesterday marked an important occurrence among the catholics of this city and vicinity in the solemn dedication of St. Mary’s Church in the fifth ward. The day was one particularly appropriate to the joyous event and not only by reason of the delightful weather, nature being attractive in a degree quite unsurpassed, but also on account of the great religious event which the catholics the world over commemorated: the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin. It was indeed a beautiful determination, that the church here named in token of love of Mary should be dedicated to holy service on the day set apart by the Catholic World for her special honor. Early in the morning services were held in the other churches of the city at which the attendance was large but it was evident to all observers that the solemn and imposing ceremonies to take place at St. Mary’s Church attracted unusual attention and caused earnest anxiety on the part of all present.

As early as 9 o’clock the various Catholic Societies began to make their appearance on the street in the vicinity of their respective halls clad in their society regalia of green and gold. They collected in large numbers and soon moved up Main Street to Third where the procession formed under the direction of Grand Marshall Michael Cook. About this time invited organizations from Watkins, Waverly and Horseheads arrived at the depot arrayed in full regalia where they were met by the Emmet Band, the St. Mary’s Society and the President of the Catholic Societies of Elmira and escorted to the place where the societies were formed and awarded their places in line.

Promptly at half-past nine at the word of command of the Grand Marshall the procession began to move down Main Street headed by the excellent and well trained Emmet Band who along the line discoursed sweet and strong music.

The St. Mary’s Temperance Association Society of Watkins, under James Powers president occupied the first position in the ranks and presented a fine appearance having upwards of seventy men in line. The Catholic Temperance Society of Waverly came next, making, as was to be expected a creditable showing for their young and surprisingly prosperous and successful organization. P.G. Masterson, Esq., is the efficient president and they had about sixty men in line.

The Horseheads Society occupied the next position in the procession and though but recently organized, turned out in such large numbers as to make an impression among the bystanders quite complimentary to its president Rick Donovan. Following came the many Catholic Societies of this city, the oldest being first, and the remainder taking positions according to the date of their organization. The S.S. Peter and Paul’s Benevolent Society looked exceedingly well turning out in large numbers, and the Rev. Fr. Matthew T.A. Society was noticeably prominent both in point of numerical strength and attractiveness of regalia. The CYMB and TA pleased everybody, their handsome carriages and fine appearance winning the approving smiles and glances of the pretty damsels along the route. The fine appearance of St. Patrick’s Society entitles that organization to much credit and the St. Mary’s T.A. Society attached to the church that was dedicated, cannot be too highly complimented. The Catholic Knights of Temperance occupying the last place in the procession made an effect upon the bystanders, attracting along the march intense interest.

Each of the societies received approving and encomiastic remarks from all along the line of march which was down Main Street, across the bridge and up South Main Street to Franklin and up Franklin to the church. Every Society participating in the parade then entered the church, its members taking the seats reserved for them on either side of the center aisle. Immediately after the societies had become seated and the Sacred and Soul inspiring ceremonies commenced, the church being fairly crowded with devout and reverential worshipers. The Very Rev. Bishop Ryan of Buffalo, preceded by several acolytes, neatly dressed in black and white, and all the attending clergymen robed in white then came from the Sacristy and knelt before the Altar. Then a prayer was devoutly offered, at the conclusion of which the Bishop and Clergy in solemn procession went to the outside of the Church which was sprinkled with Holy Water by Bishop Ryan. Returning to the inside the Bishop and the Clergy again knelt before the Altar and chanted the beautiful service prescribed by the Catholic Church after which they moved through the several aisles chanting and singing as they went, when the interior was also blessed by the Bishop. At the conclusion of the dedicatory ceremonies which were strikingly beautiful and impressive, even to those not of the Catholic faith, a solemn Pontifical High Mass was celebrated by Bishop Ryan which impressed all with its beauty and grandeur, while it awakened feelings of intense admiration for the glorious religion in the hearts of the many faithful and devout Catholics.

The Bishop was assisted in the Mass by the Very Rev. William Gleeson, assistant priest, Fathers Colgan, and Cunningham, Deacons of Honor Fr. Liddy, Deacon and Father Bloomer Subdeacon. It was throughout, impressive in a great degree from the high station in the church of the pious celebrant and the gorgeous robes and vestments of the assisting clergy. The Altar presented a scene of surpassing beauty, being charmingly and artistically decorated and ornamented with the choicest floral gifts while the costly Altar furniture, to be used permanently in the church, attracted the admiring attention of every observer.

The sermon by the Rev. Father Rice, president of the Academy of Our Lady Of The Angels at Suspension Bridge, was an unusually interesting one, claiming during its delivery the closest attention. We had attempted to give a complete report of the entire sermon but we were so fully entranced by the efforts, that it became impossible to take satisfactory or sufficient notes.

It was eminently eloquent, powerful and convincing and was listened to with scrupulous attention by everyone present. One rarely has the opportunity of listening to one of equal merit from prelates of such abilities. It was an effort, Christian throughout in its character, and must have met hearty praise even from the most critical. At the conclusion of the sermon, the remainder of the mass was celebrated.

The music for the occasion was in charge of the competent and accomplished church organist, Mrs. Ann Sheehy and was finally and expressively welcomed by the choir, which is composed as follows: Messrs. Callahan, Maloney, O’Brien and the Misses O’Brien, Dempsey, Murphy, Kane, assisted by Miss Ryan and Mrs. McDonough of Geneva, N.Y.

They sang Mullard’s famous “Mass in G,” in an exceptional manner. Many of the beautiful solos with which the mass abounds were truthfully rendered while the offertory by Miss Ryan and Mrs. McDenough was expressive in a high degree. Much to the regret of the public the choir was obliged to content themselves with a cabinet organ, the fine instrument, in the process of building, being not sufficiently ready to allow its use.

The vespers at four in the afternoon were said and were as interesting as the ceremonies of the morning. About 120 children were confirmed by the Bishop. All of the young girls were neatly dressed in spotless white, while veils hung from the heads of each, crowned with a beautiful wreath. The altar was brilliant with lighted tapers and the church within presented a trully [sic] beautiful and gladsome aspect. After administering the rite of confirmation, Bishop Ryan addressed the children with a few words of earnest congratulation and afterwards addressed the congregation at considerable length.

The church that was dedicated yesterday was a noticeable structure situated on the corner of Franklin and Fulton Streets in the fifth ward. It will be remarked by the observer for its economical plainness and general beauty of architectural appearance together with its apparent careful and substantial construction. In external appearance it is plain but imposing. It is constructed of brick, tastefully ornamented with stone and is chiefly from a Gothic design. The brick work was all done by Patrick Murray and the roofing by Messrs. Daniels & Smith, and the completeness and evident strength and durability of the work of each reflects on them no small amount of credit. The roof is slated. Fronting on Franklin Street, there are two large towers, each sixty feet in height which add a great deal to the handsome appearance of the church front. These towers will be completed next year by the addition of a steeple to each. There are three broad entrances to the church from Franklin Street, which afford ample accommodation for the ingress and egress. Through not wholly completed, the outside of the church is both pleasing an imposing to a large degree.

The interior of the church of all is the most attractive. The fresco work is strikingly beautiful and remarkable for the pleasant and exquisite blending of colors. The whole work is finished and elegant. There is nothing superior to it in this city. All of the designs are of notable beauty and symmetry, while the colors are of that peculiar cast which makes the church appear cheerful. The walls around the altar are finished in a style that can only be approached, certainly not excelled. The ceiling represents the vault of heaven with its beautiful blue, variegated with a delicate green tinge from which myriad stars glitteringly twinkle. Just beneath, artistically delineated in old English lettering, are several beautiful religious models. The fresco work was done by Henry Allevelt of Syracuse, an artist of cultivated taste and large experience, he having frescoed two hundred churches in New York alone, besides many churches in adjoining states.

The main altar is also beautiful in its general appearance and is ornamented in a style in keeping with the surpassing beauties of the other surroundings. On each side of the church are small altars finally finished, on either side of which besides the usual neat furniture are splendid statues of Mary and Joseph.

The windows, which are of stained glass, are also beautiful in their appearance. They were manufactured and put in place by Fredericks and Steffin of Detroit and their colors are of such a character as to give additional beauty and cheerfulness to the church within. All the windows were gifts of individuals on each of which the giver’s name is inscribed. The two handsomest, situated behind the main altar, were donated by the St. Mary T. A. and B. Society and the St. Mary’s Scapular Society. The remaining were contributed by James McCadden, Mr. Cook, P.J. O’Brien, Michael Casey, Con. Connelly, John Callahan, Michael Mulcahey, Michael Moore, Humphrey O’Brien and Many McCadem and on in memory of Ella Keating.

The woodwork of the church is also handsome. The wainscoting is of Southern oak and the pews are constructed of ash and walnut. The altars, as before remarked, are neatly designed. The main altar in the sanctuary is nicely made and beautifully decorated.

The church is exceedingly large and is probably the largest of any in the city. It is 135 feet in length by 60 feet in width. The distance to the ceiling is about 45 feet.

In connection with the dedication, it may be well to state that the church was twice rebuilt. In December, 1874, as most of our readers will remember, the entire church was blown over, when nearly covered over, by a violent gale of wind. The loss by this fall, which was almost equal to the utter destruction was upwards of $10,000. Soon after this accident, which was enough to dishearten even the most sanguine and determined, Father McManus, with an energy that deserves the highest praise commenced the work of reconstruction. His people seemed discouraged, but nevertheless, he persevered and progressed and the magnificent edifice yesterday dedicated is the noble and monumental result of his tireless labors. The present structure, no considering the losses sustained, will cost, when completed, about $25,000, on which at present there is but a trifling debt. We doubt if ever such a fine showing was made by any clergyman within our observation for many years. The church stands now a magnificent and permanent monument silently giving its tribute of praise to one of the finest and ablest clergymen with which the Catholic public of this city has been blessed for many years.

Besides the construction of this new church, Fr. McManus has erected and paid for a splendid pastoral residence. A large temporary church has also been built which stands behind the new building in which, during the past three years, service has been held. This will now be vacated and will be used for a school house.

The total cost of all this work will amount to upwards of $40,000.00 of which $30,000.00 has been contributed by the people of St. Mary’s parish during the three years just past.

There were an unusual number of clergy from this and other dioceses in attendance among whom we noticed Vicar General Gleeson, Fathers McManus, of Scranton, Colgan of Corning, Kinsella of Wellsville, Quinn of Binghamton, Liddy of Watkins, Rice of Suspension Bridge, Cunningham, Bloomer, and Fr. McManus the pastors of the churches of this city, besides many others. Besides the clergy there were many gentlemen from New York, including Alexander Patton, president of the Metropolitan Catholic T. A. Union of New York, and James W. O’Brien, Secretary of the Catholic T.A. Union of America.

After the services of the dedication were brought to a close, the ladies of St. Mary’s Church served a sumptuous dinner in the building adjoining the new church, which was partaken of by the Catholic Societies of Watkins and Waverly and their friends who accompanied them. The visitors seemed to be quite pleased at the manner in which they were treated, and many were the thanks which the fair ladies who pleasingly waited on them received.

In concluding it is but fitting to note that the day was one of great interest of the Catholics of this city. It will mark a notable event in the progressive history of religion in Elmira. A splendid church so solemnly dedicated is a credit to the place and a monument to the noble pastor, Fr. McManus, who has shown rare judgment in the construction of the edifice. His cultivated taste is everywhere apparent, and particularly so in the painting above and behind the Altar, which is one famous in art, being a copy of a celebrated Bavarian work. The Stations of the Cross, fourteen in number are also from the same artist. They add largely to the beauty of the church which is second to none in Southern New York.

St. Mary's 1877 - 1881

Over a year later, a fire damaged St. Mary’s Church as was noted in the Advertiser under the date of January 20, and 22, 1877.

ST. MARY'S CHURCH FIRE

At this hour of writing, (three o’clock) St. Mary’s Catholic Church, in the Fifth Ward, is on fire, and it is feared the entire edifice will be destroyed.

The fire broke out about a quarter past one o’clock. An alarm was at once sounded – a man living near the Church running to the engine house of Eldridge Hose and giving the alarm.

The bell of the engine house was vigorously rung, carrying intelligence of the fire to this side of the river. The dense clouds of smoke seen arising were suggestive of a serious conflagration, and hundreds of citizens crowded the bridges, and looked toward the scene of the fire. When it became known that the Church was on fire, great excitement was created on the street, and there was a general rush of people from all parts of the city to the scene.

The Church is nearly a mile and a half from the hose tower and the heavy smoke made it hard work for the engines to make good time in getting to the fire. Great clouds of smoke were pouring from all the windows, and it was impossible for the firemen to get inside the building. Windows were smashed in, the water forced upon the raging fire. The fire seemed to be raging with greatest fury about the altar, in the north end of the church.

Those first at the Church ran in and endeavored to save some of the Altar furniture and pieces, but only succeeded in getting out two vestments, so rapid was the spread of the flames.

At a quarter past three o’clock, the fire was not yet extinguished. It is difficult to get water in sufficient quantities. The nearest fire hydrant is near the old factory of the Losie Manufacturing Company, two thousand feet from the Church.

It is rumored that the fire started from an explosion in the furnace in which fires had been kindled to get the Church warm for tomorrow’s services.

The burning Church is unfortunate. The walls were blown down in a storm while it was being erected, involving a loss of several thousand dollars. It was erected at a cost of nearly $65, 000, and it has not been occupied for more than three years. It is located on the corner of Franklin and Fulton Streets, just opposite the Southern Tier Orphan’s Home.

The Pastor is the Rev. J.C. McManus. The great loss incurred by the fire will be a serious blow to the society.

At half-past three o’clock the firemen were still at work. The entire destruction of the Church is feared. The Church is a substantial brick one and among the best structures in the city.

Following the fire, the old Church was pressed into service as we read in the Daily Gazette of January 26, 1877.

When the Gazette went to press on Saturday afternoon the fire reported in St. Mary’s Church was in progress, and all the reports from the scene seemed to indicate that the building would be seriously damaged, if not entirely destroyed. Happily the fire was got under subjection sooner than at first was thought possible; and it is a matter for congratulation not only among the congregation, but equally gratifying to the public at large, that the damage of the fire is by no means as serious as was, in the excitement that prevailed at the time, forebodingly anticipated.

There is a hydrant very near the corner of Fulton and Franklin Streets, where the Church is located. This afforded a ready and sufficient water supply. P. Carroll, of Steamer No. 2, when the alarm sounded, at once hurried to Goodell Five’s house and took that steamer to the fire. The other steamers are too heavy to draw through the bad roads to a fire. In a commendably short time three steamers were ready for service. In Lines of hose were taken through the front door of the Church to that part of the Church near the Altar, where the flames were breaking through the floor. A copious deluge of water from the steamer soon checked the fire and eventually extinguished it. The firemen worked discreetly and energetically as they always do. It was almost as much as a man’s life was worth at one time to enter the Church, so densely full was it with smoke; but by means of a side window and through the cellar the firemen ingressed and fought the fire at every available point successfully. All the various Hose Companies were represented. Chief engineer Landy and Assistant Hyde made judicious and effective distribution of their gallant fire fighters.

When the fire broke out the Rev. J.C. McManus, the Pastor, was calling on the Pastor of SS. Peter and Paul’s Church, Rev. Mr. Cunningham. He at once hurried to the scene and coolly assisted in efforts to save the Church. He was first to approach the Altar and at imminent risk of himself succeeded in carrying out to safety the Sacred vessels that rested in the Tabernacle.

The fire originated from one of the registers, the large center one, it is thought, directly in front of the Altar. A fire had been started to warm the Church for Sunday services. The heat may have set fire to the wood work, or paper or some other inflamable [sic] substance must have lodged in the register, ignited.

The Altar was not burned. Quite a large section of the floor in front is burned away or cut into to get at the fire, and about twenty costly seats fronting the Altar, destroyed by the fire. The principal damage is from smoke and water, which defaced and blackened the walls which had been elaborately and elegantly frescoed at a large cost and greatly injured much of the plastering on the walls. Much of this will have to be retouched, ore entirely repainted. The total damage it is judged will be in the neighborhood of $2,500.

There is an insurance of $10,000 on the Church, $5,000 in the House of New York and $5,000 in the London Assurance Corporation of which companies Sly and Frost are agents in this city.

St. Mary’s Church congregation and pastor are fortunate in escaping so well. The loss of the Church, which is one of the finest in Western New York, if not in the state, would have been an overwhelming one to them and a misfortune to the city.

Owing to the extensive damage done to the new Church of St. Mary’s in the Fifth Ward, which will take some time to repair, the old Church, in which the congregation previously worshiped, and just adjoining the brick one, is being fitted up for worship. It will be occupied next Sunday and used until the new Church is ready for service.

We then skip over the years until Father McManus was transferred to St. Joseph’s Parish at Batavia, New York, in April, 1880.

Rev. Michael O’Dwyer, pastor of Salamanca, was appointed to take over St. Mary’s, Elmira after Father McManus Left.

Father O’Dwyer’s career was a most interesting one. He was born about 1828 near Nenagh, County Tipperary, Ireland.

Father Michael O'Dwyer

Second Pastor of St. Mary's
___________________
He spent some time at the Irish College in Paris. Here he prepared for his life work and later went to Algiers in company with the famous Marshall McMahon, conquerer [sic] of Algiers, where to attached himself to the Marshall’s Staff and remained several years as a soldier of fortune.

In the year 1863 he came to America and was adopted into the diocese of Buffalo by Bishop Timon. He was ordained in 1866 and up to the time he came to Elmira, had been resident pastor at Newfane, French Creek, Warsaw and Salamanca.

We next go to the year 1881 and quote three articles from the Daily Gazette of July of that year.

The dramatic club of St. Mary’s Church, Fifth Ward, will give an entertainment in the school house, formerly used as a church, on Friday evening next the 15th, when the laughable farce entitled “More Blunders Than One” will be produced. (Daily Gazette, July 9, 1881).

The following is the programme of the entertainment for the benefit of St. Mary’s Church on Thursday evening next. The Racket Family Quintette [sic] Orchestra will furnish the Music.

Overture……………………………………………..…………Orchestra
Declamation….….The Fall of King Guillotin….……..Mort B. Sullivan
Quartette……………………………..…Come Where the Lilies Bloom
Recitation….Selections from “Josiah Allen’s Wife”…Maggie Calligan
Character Song……………………………….……….William P. Morris
Select Readings…”Conner”……………………..Miss Emma O’Farrell
Music……………………………………………………………Orchestra

To conclude with the laughable farce in two acts, “More Blunders Than One”, with the following cast of characters: Mr. John Connolly, Mr. J.H. Callihan, Mr. J.H. Keefe, Mr. John D. Sullivan, Miss Annie Lennon, Miss Kate Calligan, and Miss Matie Brady.

There will be a lawn festival in connection with the entertainment. (Gazette, July 18, 1881)

A much larger hall could have been filled last night than the one in which the concert for the benefit of St. Mary’s Church was held. Every seat and all the standing room was occupied. The ceiling of the hall, which is in the old church building, is very low, and for that reason those taking part in the entertainment worked under great disadvantage. The orchestra music was furnished by the Racket Family. Mr. Mort Sullivan declaimed – he has a very good voice. A quartette of unusually good home talent sang “Come Where the Lilies Bloom”, and responded to an encore. Miss Maggie Calligan recited a selection from “Josiah Allen’s Wife”, which was quite fun provoking. Miss Anna Noble sang in her usual sweet and pleasant manner a solo entitled “Kerry Dances”, and responded to an encore, after which Miss Emma O’Farrell gave a select reading from “Conner”. The entertainment closed with a laughable farce entitled “more Blunders Than One”. All the actors of the evening did themselves credit, as every part was well learned and carefully rehearsed. (Gazette – July 22, 1881)

St. Mary's happenings 1888 - 1895

The next reference is to Holiday entertainment. Noted in the Elmira Daily Gazette and Free Press of December 11, 1888.

HOLIDAY ENTERTAINMENT

During the holidays, the children at St. Mary’s Church, Southport, purpose to give a series of entertainments. The programme will consist of musical and literary exercises, views and lectures, to commence on Friday evening after Christmas and continue during the following week, closing with the grand festival Saturday night.

We insert here a paragraph from the History of the Valley and Chemung County by Turner, published in 1892 which is of interest:

St. Mary’s Church in the fifth ward was largely due to the labors of the Rev. James C. McManus, a constant and indefatigable laborer and usually successful in the building up of churches. He always held a high place in the regard of his superiors and his people. He came from Watkins, where he had built a church, and put St. Mary’s on the surest of foundations. The first church was built in 1872, a frame one, and was replaced in 1874 by the present brick structure costing in the neighborhood of $30,000. Father McManus was afterward transferred to Batavia, where he died in January 1882. His sister is the wife of John Moore, of the Albany Telegram. The present pastor of St. Mary’s is the Rev. Michael O’Dwyer, a revered pastor and well loved man of high natural abilities and scholarly attainments. He began his preparation for the ministry in France and completed his studies at the Seminary at Suspension Bridge, N.Y. He was ordained a priest on August 19, 1866 by Bishop Timon, the first bishop of Buffalo. He had charge of several parishes, being successful in all. In August 1891 he celebrated the twenty fifth anniversary of his ordination in a manner that will be long remembered by his people and friends.

This takes us over to a Columbus Day celebration in 1892 from the Gazette and Free Press, Oct. 13, 1892:

The young people of St. Mary’s Church celebrated Columbus Day last evening with a most excellent and appropriate musical, instrumental and literary entertainment at Miller’s Hall. The large hall was completely filled with members of the parish and their friends. The entertainment was in charge of Miss Rose Brady, the church organist. Those who took part were Misses May and Angie Geer, the little daughters of Chas. Geer; Father Trautlein, John Callahan, Dennis Sullivan, Miss Nellie O’Day, Miss Agnes Reardon and Miss Nellie Ryan. Father Lafferty of St. Mary’s Church delivered an eloquent and interesting lecture upon Columbus Day. After the entertainment an elegant spread was served.

In the Daily Gazette, Dated December 27, 1892, is carried a description of the Christmas Service for that year.

The services at St. Mary’s Catholic Church on Sunday morning were beautiful and impressive. The musical program was composed of some of the choicest selections of sacred music and their rendition was excellent. The performance of Amos French on the violin and John Young the cornetist were especially commendable. Miss Brady’s organ selections were beautifully rendered. Father Lafferty, the assistant to Father O’Dwyer, preached two sermons appropriate to the occasion.

A financial report for the year 1893 was mentioned in the Gazette, January 29, 1894:

The annual report of the finances of St. Mary’s Church show that the church is free from debt. The report states that $5,018.89 was received during the year, and that after the annual expenses were paid, $51.49 remained in the treasury.

Father O’Dwyer made an appeal to his parishioners for aid in 1895 as reported in the Daily Gazette, February 4, 1895:

ST. MARY’S AID
CATHOLIC WOMEN OF THE SOUTHSIDE ORGANIZE
FOR CHARITABLE PURPOSES

Yesterday morning Rev. Father O’Dwyer told his congregation that this year for the first time in the history of St. Mary’s parish, it was necessary to provide some means for the indigent of the parish. There were more cases where good people of the parish could show their charitable instincts than ever before. Yesterday afternoon the women of the parish got together and formed St. Mary’s Aid Society. A large number enrolled their names upon the charter and an organization was effected. Mrs. Wheeler was elected president; Mrs. Dempsey, vice president; Mrs. Boylan, treasurer. These organizations have done great good in other parishes, and doubtless will in St. Mary’s.

St. Mary's 1895 to 1898

In February, 1895 an entertainment was held at Miller’s Hall. The Daily Gazette of February 21 reported:


A GRAND TIME
THE ALTAR SOCIETY AND CHOIR OF ST. MARY’S CHURCH
ENTERTAIN
A Rich Musical Programme, a Splendid Supper and
A Merry Dance participated in by a Large and
Enthusiastic Gathering

Last evening the Altar Society and choir of St. Mary’s church gave an entertainment and dance, and served supper at Miller’s Hall. There was a large and enthusiastic crowd in attendance and the affair was highly successful, financially and socially. Supper was served from 6 till 12 o’clock p.m., and was one of the most delicious and appetizing layouts seen at a church affair in a good many moons, and those who sat down to the tables well satisfied their eating desires. Those in charge of the tables were: Mrs. Ellen Keavin, who is always to be found an earnest worker for all of the church’s causes, and Mrs. Jerry Bergan, Mrs. Thomas McInerney, Mrs. John Galvin, Miss Mame Brown, Mrs. Carroll, Mrs. John Dempsey, Mrs. Lorden, Mrs. Connelly, Mrs. O’Shay, Miss Sullivan, Miss Kane, Mrs. O’Leary, Miss Brown, Mrs. Hanrahan, Miss Kate Flynn. The program rendered was delightful and was listened to by the vast audience with absorbing interest. John Barnett sang “Farewell, Marguerite” with a strong, sweet tenor voice, and highly pleased the assemblage. Miss Maggie O’Brien sang “Olcott’s Serenade”, and received an encore. Miss O’Brien is a charming singer. “Come with Me” a duet by Messrs. T.A. Reynolds and Dennis Sullivan, was richly enjoyed and loudly applauded. John Callahan sang two of Olcott’s songs and the applause evoked was tremendous. Professor Ralph Mulcare played a cornet solo to the delight of everybody. Mr. Mulcare is one of the best cornetists in this section of the state. “Somebody Loves Me”, was rendered by Miss May Liddy, followed, upon an encore by an Irish ballad. Miss Liddy has a charming appearance and her sweet, musical voice combined with it, immediately elicit the good graces of an audience, so when Miss Liddy completes her song, rapturous applause greets her rendition, and last evening was no exception.

T.A. Reynolds has a rich tenor voice and sang, “Tell Her I Love Her So”, perfectly. To conclude a quartette, consisting of Mrs. G.C. Boylan, Anna Flynn, and Messrs. Reynolds and Sullivan rendered a charming selection. Mrs. Boylan, who is possessed of a highly cultured voice, leading. The hall was then cleared and Mulcare’s and George’s Orchestra furnished delightful music for dancing which continued until one o’clock a.m. St. Mary’s Church is supplied with as fine a choir and as pretty an altar as any church in the city, and it is the young ladies and gentlemen who had charge of this entertainment who make it so. Rev. Father M.J. O’Dwyer, the pastor, recently celebrated his 25th anniversary as a priest. Father O’Dwyer’s faultless execution of the duties of pastor, his tender heart, kindly words and charitable deeds have endeared him to his people so firmly that no earthly knife could sever the ties that bind them together. Like the late lamented Father Cunningham, Father O’Dwyer is ever jocular and good natured, and too many words of praise could not be earnestly said of him. The choir and altar society caused the church to be refurnished and have made other temporary and permanent decorations and improvements, which have been highly appreciated by all.

The choir is composed of Miss Rose Brady, organist; Mrs. G.C. Boylan, Misses Ellen Ryan, Mary Carroll, Maggie O’Brien, May Liddy and Messrs. John Callahan, T.A. Reynolds, John Nugent, Dennis Sullivan, and John Barnett. Father O’Dwyer has charge of the altar society. The stage decorations, potted plants and palms were donated by Rawson. Messrs. Jerry Bergan, Dennis Dempsey and Thomas Sullivan had charge of the door.

A reference is made to the completion of the steeple in the Elmira Daily Gazette and Free Press, July 2, 1895:

Workmen are engaged in completing the steeple on St. Mary’s church on Franklin St. The contract for the work was secured by Contractor John C. Williamson.

This brings us to the articles in the Gazette of Feb. 25 and 26, 1896:

On the evening of the 27th, a musical and literary treat will be given the people of Elmira in St. James Hall. The best musical talent in the city has been engaged for the occasion. The Reverend M.B. Curry of New York will deliver his celebrated lecture on the “Martyrdom of the Irish Nation.” The proceeds will go to St. Mary’s Church. The following program will be rendered tomorrow evening at St. James Hall:

Evening Bells -----Messrs. P.H. Stapleton, J. Buckley, C. Conlon, J. Hart
Pretty Little Island in the Ocean……………………………..Miss M. O’Day
Tenor Solo………………………………………………..Mr. James Buckley
The Harp That Once Through Tara’s Hall……………..……Miss M. Liddy
“The Martyrdom of the Irish Nation”…….…….…..Rev. Father M.B. Curry
The Shamrock…………………………………...……….…Miss M. O’Brien
Farewell…………………………Messrs. Stapleton, Buckley, Conlon, Hart

The choir presented a party on Oct. 13, 1896 which was carried in the Gazette of Oct. 14, 1896:

The members of St. Mary’s church choir and their friends enjoyed an excellent musical and a hop at Bundy Hall last evening. Selections were given by Mrs. Louis Duhl, Mrs. Thomas Durant, Misses Maggie and Anna Shay, and Messrs. Suganty, McCaffery, Sullivan, Morgan, Reynolds and Dowling.

Mulcare’s orchestra furnished music for the dancing.

At this time the Southern Tier counties of Tioga, Chemung, Schuyler and Steuben which had been in the diocese of Buffalo, were transferred to the diocese of Rochester. This is mentioned in the Gazette dated January 22, 1897:

At a meeting of the priests of this diocese held yesterday in Corning to hear the official announcement of the division of the diocese, the Rev. M. O’Dwyer and Rev. J. Moriarty of St. Mary’s church, Elmira were present.

Another reference to this was made in the Gazette of February 4, 1897:

All the priests of the recently enlarged diocese of Rochester gathered at St. Bernard’s Seminary on the Charlotte Boulevard yesterday to partake of a dinner tendered by their Bishop Rt. Rev. Bernard J. McQuaid and to spend the afternoon in an informal social manner. Rev. M. O’Dwyer and Rev. J. Moriarty of St. Mary’s Church, Elmira, were present.

Bishop McQuaid, bishop of Rochester, administered confirmation on October 5th, 1897. We read in the Gazette for that date:

Right Rev. Bernard McQuaid, Bishop of Buffalo, administered the sacrament of confirmation to a large class of children and some grown people at St. Mary’s Church this morning. He was assisted by the pastor Father O’Dwyer, Fathers Bloomer, Long, Gefell, Moriarty, Climer, Trautlein, Dean, Maley, Dunn, O’Shay and Bopple.

A number of people witnessed the ceremony and Bishop McQuaid delivered a pleasing address, particularly to the children.

St. Mary’s prowess in athletics was evidenced as early as 1897 where the Gazette reports under the date of December 4th of year:

A very interesting game of football took place yesterday afternoon on the corner of Euclid Avenue and First Street between representative teams from St. Mary’s parochial school and St. Patrick’s.

The game began at 3 o’clock. Captain Cahill of St. Mary’s won the toss and chose to defend the southern goal. After a few minutes of hard play half-back Sullivan broke through his opponents’ line and by a brillant [sic] run scored the first touchdown for St. Mary’s. During the remainder of the first half the honors were evenly divided, neither team being able to score. The second half was more stubbornly contested. St. Patrick’s forwards played with redoubled energy but St. Mary’s line was impregnable. The most brilliant play of the game was made by Captain Cahill. Securing the ball from the quarter-back on a long pass he ran around the end dodging all the backs until he landed the sphere behind the opponents’ goal making the score 8 to 0 in favor of St. Mary’s.

The game was a splendid specimen of clean gentlemanly football. Messrs. Cahill, Sullivan, Fennell, and Widman played with great skill and seemed to be ubiquitous throughout the game. Messrs. Sullivan, Ford, and Foley carried off the honors for St. Patrick’s. The tackling of Captain Sullivan was one of the features of the game. Mr. Scales, an old football player, acted as referee, while Messrs. Brink and Murtaugh acted as time keepers.

An interesting report was given by Father O’Dwyer in the Gazette of February 1, 1898:

At the Sunday morning services Father O’Dwyer of St. Mary’s Church read a synopsis of his report to Bishop McQuaid in regard to the statistics of his parish. He said that there were 1,500 Catholics in his parish, divided into 300 families. There were, he said, 335 children attending the parochial school. The receipts for the year were $4,207.09.

Purchase of more property was noted in a deed recorded with the County Clerk March 2, 1898:

Deed Volume 118, Page 238, Records of the County, Chemung County, Elmira, N.Y., March 2, 1898.
Michael O’Dwyer to St. Mary’s Roman Church Society property 53 feet along Franklin St. by 150 feet in depth. Also land on Franklin St. 87 feet by 150 feet.

St. Mary's School

First mention of the new school is made in the Gazette of March 10, 1898 where it is stated:

“Work on the new $13,000 school house which Father O’Dwyer is about to erect will soon be under way.”

The Spanish American War started this same year and Father O’Dwyer delivered a sermon on patriotism which was commented on in the Gazette of March 10, 1898 in the following manner:

The Reverend Father O’Dwyer delivered a discourse Sunday on the value of patriotism. He spoke regarding the awakening spirit of patriotism in the parish and referred to three boys – Nolan, Perkins and Hanrahan, who had gone to join the Navy. He said he had not encouraged the boys to join the Navy when they talked to him about it but he felt nevertheless that the pluck and patriotism of the young men should not be discouraged. If it was shown that the Maine was destroyed by an act of Spanish treachery and war should be declared, he said that the young men of his parish should be and would be among the first to enlist. He was glad that it had been already shown that St. Mary’s parish was even at this early date ready to furnish volunteers for the service of their country.

St. Mary's School
_____________

Further evidence of the progress of the new school and convent was given publicity in the papers under the date of April 11, 1898:

The foundation for the new parochial school of St. Mary’s Parish has just been laid. The work on the structure will be immediately commenced. It will be of brick with stone trimmings and two stories in height. Father O’Dwyer has made arrangements for the construction of a brick convent.

The Gazette of May 5th of the same year mentions three new brick buildings going up at St. Mary’s:

The three large brick buildings which are being erected for the St. Mary’s parish are to be opened in the fall. One is to be used for the purposes of the parochial school, with an entertainment hall annex in the rear and a third is a convent. The parochial school building with entertainment hall annex will cost about $13,000 and the convent some $5,000 additional.

Another milestone was passed on June 29, 1898 when the Gazette carried the story of the opening of the new school:

St. Mary’s School was formally opened last evening. A large audience was present to witness the exercises which proved to be of a most interesting nature. The Queen City Band played an overture after which the guests were welcomed by Ella Richardson and Master Charles Finley. A feature of the evening was the production of “In the Days of Washington”, by the Junior class. The children were attired in costumes of the sixteenth century. “The International Flag Display” was most delightful, and called forth hearty applause.The first graduation in the new school was held July 7, 1898 and the story carried in the next day’s Gazette:

The annual commencement exercises of St. Mary’s parochial school were held last evening. The hall was prettily decorated and crowded. The first number on a program was a novel minuet by the members of the junior class. The children wore costumes of the sixteenth century. Miss Eleanor McInerny recited “Long Ago” in a delightful manner. The Brownie character song and the operetta “Titania” were greatly enjoyed. “The Confidential Clerk”, a dialogue was excellent. Mrs. Louise McInerny read the class Allegory after which the diplomas were distributed by the pastor, Rev. M. O’Dwyer.

First Graduating Class St. Mary's School, 1898

_______________

The following are the graduates: Elizabeth Gradwell, Frederick Cooklin, Harriet Keavin, Cornelius Connelly, Sarah Canna, Michael Murphy, Louise McInerny, Susan Gradwell, Harriet Colligan, Katherine Murray, Julia Murtaugh, Mary Mantell, Edward O’Shea, Henry Cashill, James Powers, Simon Fennell, Frank Finley, Dennis Sullivan, Alice Recker.

Bishop McQuaid came on August 28th to dedicate the new school. This occasion was reported in the Gazette under the dates of August 27 and 29, 1898:

Bishop McQuaid of Rochester will be in the city tomorrow to dedicate the new St. Mary’s Convent and school. The Rochester Union and Advertiser says:

“On Sunday next Bishop McQuaid will go to Elmira to dedicate the convent and school just erected by the people of St. Mary’s parish in that city. He will return to Rochester on Monday.

“The buildings are of brick, two stories in height with a basement. That to be used as the parochial school is 76x49 feet and has a parochial hall in the rear which is 82x52 feet. The school fronts on Fulton Street. The convent building faces on Franklin Street and is to be occupied by the ten Sisters of St. Joseph who have charge of the school. “Father O’Dwyer has had charge of St. Mary’s parish for nineteen years or since St. Mary’s church was erected. The school which he erected has become inadequate for the needs of the 375 pupils in attendance and about two years ago he began the movement which resulted in the erection of the present building.

“The school and parochial hall building will cost about $13,000 and the convent $5,000. The furnishings and heating will be extra. Hot water is to be used for heating purposes.”

St. Mary's Convent



______________






Bishop McQuaid was in the city yesterday and blessed St. Mary’s new buildings. He called attention to the excellence of Catholic schools and commended the facilities now provided for the parish. The bishop preached the sermon at 10:30 o’clock mass. The decorations were beautiful and were arranged by the Sisters of St. Joseph. The blessing of the convent and school occurred at 3:30 o’clock before an immense congregation. The bishop, attended by the City priests visited each building and conducted dedicatory services. He then delivered an able and scholarly sermon in the church. Among other things he said in order to properly educate a child the most careful attention must be paid to the instructors who are placed in charge of the schools, both as to their educational and religious training.

The school buildings and apparatus must be as modern and improved as can be found. The rooms must be well heated and ventilated. The furnishings and decorations, if any, should be of such a nature that they would cause the child to think. Useless articles, the bishop said, had no place in the school room. He highly complimented the parish of St. Mary’s upon their new structures and expressed the opinion after he had carefully examined them that none better could be found in the diocese.

The benediction of the Blessed sacrament concluded the ceremonies. The music was excellent.

An entertainment held on Sept. 12, 1898 was noted on Sept. 13 in the Gazette.

Some of the young people of St. Mary’s Church gave an entertainment last evening and delighted a large audience at St. Mary’s Hall on Franklin Street. The “Irish Patriot” was the play presented and members of the cast were: Mrs. George Brickwedde, Thomas Reynolds, Neil Maloney, Gilbert Devine, Frederick Berry, George Bamberry, Miss Isabelle Ross and Rose Perry.

The members acquitted themselves admirably and owing to the great success of last evening’s performance it has been decided to repeat it again tonight. Little Dorothy and Connie Berry were loudly applauded for their clever singing specialities [sic] between the acts.

To help defray the expenses of the new building a Fair was held in the Fall of 1898. This is reported in the Gazette under the dates of Oct. 31, Nov. 1, and Nov. 3:

The fair of St. Mary’s Church will open in the entertainment hall of St. Mary’s parochial school tonight and will continue for ten days. The proceeds are to be used towards diminishing the debt caused by the erection of the parochial school and convent. There will be entertainment each evening and on Sunday evening next a sacred concert will be given. (Gazette, Oct. 31, 1898)

The first day of the St. Mary’s Church Fair opened last evening at the new parochial school under a blaze of glory and the most favorable promises of being a success. The young ladies were on hand looking more charming than ever and bidding everyone a hearty welcome. The donations have been very generous. Father O’Dwyer presided over the entrance door and punched the tickets as easily as the oldest conductor on the Erie would do. The flags which are draped about the pillars of the hall were artistically arranged by Messrs. Walz and Brown of Architect Considine’s office.

As one enters the hall, the first booth that attracts attention is the one decorated with blue and white bunting and silver tinsel in outline. This is the booth of the children of St. Mary’s. Miss Julia Spillane is the head of the booth. The aids are: Misses Nora Deneen, Kate Connelly, Sarah Canan, Hannah Dempsey, Mrs. Cavin, Miss Julia Lordon, Mary Cavin, Bessie Deneen, Kittie Collins, the Misses Murtaugh, Alice O’Connor, Lena Moghenham, Nora Connelly, Maggie Spillane, Maggie Bresenham, Joe Carroll, Julia Murphy, Katie Liddy, Nellie Galvin, Kate Sullivan and Anna Collins.

The beautiful L.C.B.A. booth next attracts the eye. Miss Nellie Buckley has charge of this booth and with her are Mrs. Harry Grady, Mrs. Julia Kingston, Mrs. Ellen Lorden, Mrs. Mary Wickham, Mrs. B. Lynch, Mrs. Anna Spillane, Mrs. Katherine Watts, Mrs. Johanna Cavin, Mrs. McInerney, Katie Leary. There is an ice cream parlor at one side.

The chair booth is prettily decorated with pink, green and blue bunting. Miss Rose Brady, organist of the church, is the head, and aiding her are Mrs. Boylen, and Misses Mary Liddy, Julia Galvin, Mary Galvin, Maggie O’Day, Jennie Costello, Mary Cannelly, Delia Holleran, Mary Carroll, Nellie Ready, Nellie Gilbert, Mary Collin, Katherine Burns, Anna Holleran, Nellie Gahen.

The dining room is most inviting. The caterer is E. Murphy. The president is Mrs. J.B. Connelly and her aides are: Mrs. O’Shay, Mrs. Daniels, Mrs. Crotty, Misses Maggie Newcomb, Sadie Lennan, Tessie Daniels, Alice Ownes. The evening branch No. 136 of the L.C.B.A. will attend the supper; Wednesday evening The Father Mathew Society, Thursday, Branch 112 L.C.B.A.; Friday, all the societies of St. Mary’s Parish.

There will be an entertainment at 3 o’clock Saturday afternoon for all public school children.


"Flags of Nations: -- 1898
___________________

The drill called “The Flags of Nations: which is prettily executed by a number of young girls is worth seeing. France was represented by Frances Delaney, Honor Catchpole, Bessie Stapleton, Alice Hart. Germany’s representatives were Anna Burns, Libbie Burns, Hattie Fitzgerald, Marguerite Richardson. Anna Nichols, Margaret Gradwell, Gertie O’Brien, Louise Hanrahan were from Switzerland. Holland was illustrated by Mary Donovan, Nellie Sullivan, Genevieve Ready, Ella Bayer. Scotland was represented by Nellie Gray, Alice Galvin, Lena Galvin and Olive Trainor. Teresa Ready, Mary Collins, Josephine McInerney, Agnes Cavin were from Italy. Ireland was represented by Ella DeLaney, Katie Galvin, Anna Cherry and Loretta O’Leary. The Goddess of Liberty was Miss Jennie Cusick. Her dress being made from the American flag.

The fair will continue until November 9th and interesting programs have been prepared for the various evenings during which the fair will be in progress. (Gazette, Nov. 1, 1898)

The St. Mary’s Church Fair last evening was the usual great success. The young ladies were ever present and won the dollars and dimes of the patrons. A number of the members of the Father Mathew Society attended supper.

The Delsarte Drill was greatly enjoyed. It was given by Misses Julia Murtaugh, Sarah Cannan, Harriet Keavin, Frances Lennon, Teresa Ready, Katie Hayes, Jennie Cusick, Nellie Considine, Margaret Hanrahan, Louise McInerney, Elizabeth Gradwell, Alice Risker, E. McInerney, F. Delaney. They sang well, in chorus, the song “Old Friend”. (Gazette, Nov. 3, 1898)

The unprecendted [sic] success of this Fair is noted in the Gazette of Nov. 8 which notes that it will be carried on for several more days.

The St. Mary’s Fair, which is being held in St. Mary’s Church, is a bigger success than even its promoters had anticipated. It is a great place to spend a pleasant evening. It was the general idea to end the Fair tonight, but on account of the great success it will be continued during the remainder of the week and will end on Saturday night. At that time the contests for the School of Commerce and Warner’s Business College scholarships will end. All the remainder of the week will be full of excitement and interest attending the result of the contest and donations.

The second day of the fair opened last evening with a large attendance. Pretty maidens, handsomely crowned, were present in large numbers and the gay booths came in for their share of attention. A very pretty minuet was danced on the stage by the children. The Red Men attended the supper in a body.

Miss B. McMahon wishes to thank the following who so kindly donated to her for the benefit of the fair: Mrs. A, Samuels, valuable imported cover for sofa pillows; Mr. Hubbell, oak table; Mosher & DeWaters, carriage robe; Mrs. J. Walker, handpainted china plate; Mr. Heller, coffee pot; Miss Anna Campbell, Moquet rug; Miss Mary McMahon, vases; Mrs. T. Fitzgerald, child’s hat; Mr. Van Nort, candy; H.N. Hoffman, flowers; Mr. LaCharme, flowers; cash from F.X. Disney, D.N. Heller, Seymour Copeland and Mrs. D. Donohue.

Mrs. T.J. McInerny of branch No. 112 L.C.B.A. wishes to thank branches 136 and 112 L.C.B.A. and branch 150 C.M.B.A., for their liberal donations to her for the benefit of St. Mary’s fair.

That this Fair was a tremendous success is born out by the reports in the papers of November 15 and 21 of the same year as follows:

The St. Mary’s Church Fair closed last night. The donated articles with the exception of the Stearns bicycle and the bedroom suite were raffled off last night. The latter will be disposed of by chances previous to the dance tomorrow evening. The scholarship for Warners Business College was won by Dennis Sullivan, who had 1,175 votes and the school of commerce scholarship went to Thomas Casey who had 590 votes. The fair was a great success financially and socially. (Nov. 15, 1898)

According to the report read by Father O’Dwyer yesterday, the Fair of St. Mary’s Church proved to be an immense financial success. Only $311 were taken in in admissions at the door, showing a paid attendance of 3110. However, the total receipts, which were also the net receipts, for there were no expenses, were $2,836.23. Great credit is due to the ladies having the Fair in charge.

The summary of the proceeds are as follows:

L.C.B.A. table, president, Mrs. Nellie Buckley…… $ 565.23
Refreshment table, president, Mrs. John B. Connelly…413.00
Children of Mary table, president, Miss Julia Spillane… 410.00
Proceeds from bicycle sale………………………… 397.00
Amount received from Sisters of St. Joseph and children……. 319.00
Door receipts……………………………………………..311.00
Proceeds from scholarship certificates………… 175.00
Choir table, president, Miss Rose Brady……… 171.00
Personal donation………………………………………75.00
______
Total……………………………………………$2,836.23

Donations were received as follows:

L.C.B.A. Branch 199……………………….$ 15.00
L.C.B.A. Branch 136………………………… 15.00
L.C.B.A. Branch 112………………………. 15.00
C.M.B.A., Branch of St. Patrick’s Parish, No. 150 … 10.00

On Thursday night the young ladies in charge of the Fair will give a hop. (Nov. 21, 1898)

The Gazette notes Christmas, 1898 as follows in its issue of Dec. 27, 1898:

The Midnight Mass service held Christmas Eve in all five of the Roman Catholic churches were largely attended. The Christmas donations to the priests of St. Mary’s were from $1,000 to $1,200 each.

Even in 1899 the people of St. Mary’s like to eat as were read in the Elmira Daily advertiser, February 14, 1899:

The young ladies of the choir at St. Mary’s Church entertained a large number of their friends at a dancing party last evening at St. Mary’s hall. Draperies of red, white and blue bunting formed the artistic decorations. Charles O’Brien furnished the dancing music. A delicious supper was served during the evening.

St. Patrick’s Day was celebrated in a most appropriate manner last as follows:

St. Patrick’s Day was celebrated in a most appropriate manner last evening by members of St. Mary’s parochial school. The occasion being one of the most auspicious events in the history of the school. The principal feature of the evening’s program was a lecture entitled “The Irish-American” by John Murtaugh of Cornell University.

The spacious auditorium was beautifully decorated with flags of different proportions in honor of the occasion, and long before Mr. Murtaugh’s appearance every seat in the room was occupied, while a great number were compelled to remain standing in the rear of the room.

Mr. Murtaugh’s appearance was greeted with long and hearty applause, which had hardly subsided when Father O’Dwyer arose and eulogized the speaker in his usual clever manner.

Following Mr. Murtaugh’s highly interesting and instructive lecture a comedy in five acts entitled “The Deacon” was enacted by the Alumni of the school. The members of the cast who have been under the skillful training of the Sisters of St. Mary’s, conducted their different parts in a highly professional manner, gaining numerous words of praise for their excellent work.

The evening’s entertainment was a grand success even to the most trifling detail and reflected much credit on the Sisters of St. Mary’s, who but repeated by their efforts the success attained at the opening exercises of the school held last summer. Members of the case: Thomas Hart, Edward O’Shea, Francis O’Shea, James Powers, Simon Fennell, Frank Finley, Daniel Finley, Ella Burns, Louise McInerney, Sara Cannon, M. Francis Lennon, Bessie Nolan and Helen Grey. (Advertiser, Mar. 18, 1899)